Title: American Officer Post by: WildZontar on February 06, 2011, 11:21:33 am Can anyone explain why the armor for the Officer was changed? I fail to see what the point of it was.
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: chefarzt on February 06, 2011, 11:31:44 am Tbh u also fail to keep ur lil sausage fingers away from the keyboard.
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Tymathee on February 06, 2011, 12:03:48 pm Can anyone explain why the armor for the Officer was changed? I fail to see what the point of it was. i never understood either, all the other officers get heroic armor, at least give it soldier armor or something. its supposed to be an assault officer and it died too easily already Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Killer344 on February 06, 2011, 12:06:55 pm Ugh, they don't have heroic armor, they have heroic critical (like the US officer still has), we changed it from elite to infantry to stop them from being used to roll over unupgraded squads.
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Mysthalin on February 06, 2011, 12:07:17 pm He's NOT supposed to be a one-man ranger squad lol.
To be fair, he's still essentially 2 ranger guys in one, what with the passive regen. If anything, he should get nerfed even further. Also, the two officers (Lieut and Capt) that have heroic armour also have half the HP of the US officer. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: RoyalHants on February 06, 2011, 12:08:49 pm He's NOT supposed to be a one-man ranger squad lol. and dont have tomphsons To be fair, he's still essentially 2 ranger guys in one, what with the passive regen. If anything, he should get nerfed even further. Also, the two officers (Lieut and Capt) that have heroic armour also have half the HP of the US officer. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: WildZontar on February 06, 2011, 12:40:25 pm Tbh u also fail to keep ur lil sausage fingers away from the keyboard. Dude, get it right, my fingers are macaroni, not sausage. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: skaffa on February 06, 2011, 01:22:14 pm Wasnt the US Officer recently nerfed, by changing his rape weapon ?
Should just make its offensive abilities weaker if he is too strong, but keep the survivabilty high, imo. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Killer344 on February 06, 2011, 01:45:45 pm ummm... he still has 140HP and heroic critical?
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: skaffa on February 06, 2011, 02:07:01 pm elite armor > infantry armor ?
Gives you the ability to keep him alive better, last patch when I played US the only problem was US officer raping units up close, that was recently changed I assume then. His offensive power was a problem and fixed. His defensive power was no balance problem and this change not nessecary and is the wrong change to make if the problem lies in his gun being to effective. Depends as well if you want to design the 'offensive front line' officer that he must be able to kill things but must not live long enough so he can kill too much, I guess thats the idea behind it. I personally prefered to see him being weaker in killing, but more effective is staying alive so you can still use him on the front line but is able to survive longer so you dont have to buy too many officers. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: pqumsieh on February 06, 2011, 02:11:32 pm Yea, I've played against officer spam and I must say it is a bit over the top. At first they weakened his gun, then they added a hard cap, now they are trying to rebalanced its survivability.
Bottom line, should it be an assault officer or a support officer? The current changes make it more support oriented. It still is a very powerful unit with its smoke call in; and given the fact that it is a smoke call in that seems to reinforce the idea that it is support oriented officer. The problem is trying to establish a solution that prevents spam but at the same time makes the unit cost effective/useful. I've played with the changes, it seems fine to me; I still get what I need out of the officer and with the T4 it gets amazing command buffs. PQ edit: I had no problems keeping him alive Skaffa...Just use him like you would a LT. He still has 140 HP as others have pointed out; enough to take a tank shell and walk away. He also cant be sniped. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: TheIcelandicManiac on February 06, 2011, 02:21:39 pm edit: I had no problems keeping him alive Skaffa...Just use him like you would a LT. He still has 140 HP as others have pointed out; enough to take a tank shell and walk away. He also cant be sniped. and he dose not get suppressed so you can use him to take out saturaion minefeilds with quite ease. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: chefarzt on February 06, 2011, 02:24:54 pm also was healing super fast
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: skaffa on February 06, 2011, 02:58:57 pm Yea, I've played against officer spam and I must say it is a bit over the top. At first they weakened his gun, then they added a hard cap, now they are trying to rebalanced its survivability. Bottom line, should it be an assault officer or a support officer? The current changes make it more support oriented. It still is a very powerful unit with its smoke call in; and given the fact that it is a smoke call in that seems to reinforce the idea that it is support oriented officer. The problem is trying to establish a solution that prevents spam but at the same time makes the unit cost effective/useful. I've played with the changes, it seems fine to me; I still get what I need out of the officer and with the T4 it gets amazing command buffs. PQ edit: I had no problems keeping him alive Skaffa...Just use him like you would a LT. He still has 140 HP as others have pointed out; enough to take a tank shell and walk away. He also cant be sniped. Good post, agree. With the T4 you can keep him a bit further away as well. The armor change makes him worse up close in range of enemy infantry etc. so just have to keep him further away now. You could first rush in with officer plus inf, I guess its more dangerous now and he gets killed quite fast. With the range increase in the T4 it should be good to do that, keep him further away so he is safer. If it can still survive tank shots like before then its pretty good, because thats important imo. So gotta keep him further away/out of danger, altho then its smg and the 'frontline' role doesnt really add up. edit: So rushing it up point blank to the enemy like bfore to make him help fight/kill enemy is prolly not a good idea anymore because it will get focus fired right away and die a lot faster. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Firesparks on February 06, 2011, 03:03:53 pm Title: Re: American Officer Post by: RoyalHants on February 06, 2011, 03:23:59 pm Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Firesparks on February 06, 2011, 03:57:00 pm is it the same? the sten is just as good as the thompson, but the british are more reliant on the command bonus. Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Demon767 on February 06, 2011, 05:26:02 pm PE infantry cannot successfully kill the officers, try it yourself, no matter how many you stack up against a officer, say 3 pzgren sqauds, or 2 flammen squads or 2 assault squads, they cannot kill the officers. only way is to kill them is by a IST. something is wrong
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: WildZontar on February 07, 2011, 08:42:36 pm Wait, if the Officer was too powerful the why not just hardcap him to 2 or so and give him a different weapon?
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: spinn72 on February 07, 2011, 10:09:35 pm He's already hard capped at 3 and has a gun that is only effective at short range, so if you want to risk running him in rambo style into combat then you run the risk of losing him and his buff. Like it was said before in this thread, now he can't successfully beat 2-3 squads of Pgrens on his own.
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Demon767 on February 07, 2011, 10:43:04 pm no he can solo one squad without takign any damage and he has a backup BAR squad. literally you cannot go toe to toe because of his affective pop cap balance.
Title: Re: American Officer Post by: Firesparks on February 08, 2011, 01:25:42 am PE infantry cannot successfully kill the officers, try it yourself, no matter how many you stack up against a officer, say 3 pzgren sqauds, or 2 flammen squads or 2 assault squads, they cannot kill the officers. only way is to kill them is by a IST. something is wrong I manage to kill a lone officer with a volks squad easily this patch since the elite armor was remove. If you're still having problem with the officer this patch, maybe the RNG decided to be mean to you. The current Wehr officer and the Ami officer still have 140 hp, enough for him to survive a pziv shot (even a tiger/panther with vet1). The elite armor provide a lot of defensive bonus against rifle, which was why basic squad was having so much trouble against him. |