COH: Europe In Ruins

EIR Main Forums => Balance & Design => Topic started by: XIIcorps on April 02, 2013, 03:34:25 pm



Title: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on April 02, 2013, 03:34:25 pm
Seeing as I'm in an inquisitive mood, what are the proposed changes/ replacements of this unit ?

It's seldom seen these days, shucks I think I'm probably the only player to have fielded one in the last 6months.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: TheWindCriesMary on April 02, 2013, 03:39:08 pm
Colossus was trying them out a month or two ago after giving up on the AVRE.

They can be OK with a CCT but run into the problem of there being significantly more effective alternatives for the same cost.

Would definitely be interesting to see what proposed changes are in the works.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: TheIcelandicManiac on April 02, 2013, 03:58:59 pm
What honestly needs to be done is to bring back the mk4, Sure it was shitty but it was a cheap slow brick that could act as a shock absorber while still being able to take on the basic infantry that harrassed it.
Mk6 is pretty much the same but instead is more expensive and only getting the 75mm sherm gun for the price increase(the gun is good yes but not worth the cost).


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: NightRain on April 02, 2013, 04:02:40 pm
who the hell would want to use Mark 4s? They have 67% penetration vs Ostwinds. They are also inaccurate and the only target they can fight properly is a marder due to 200% damage modifier versus them.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on April 02, 2013, 04:04:54 pm
Colossus was trying them out a month or two ago after giving up on the AVRE.

They can be OK with a CCT but run into the problem of there being significantly more effective alternatives for the same cost.

Would definitely be interesting to see what proposed changes are in the works.
Ahh well then.

That was my understanding why use a slower then Sherman AI tank when you can use the faster then light Cromwell Sherman AI tank.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: TheIcelandicManiac on April 02, 2013, 04:10:26 pm
who the hell would want to use Mark 4s? They have 67% penetration vs Ostwinds. They are also inaccurate and the only target they can fight properly is a marder due to 200% damage modifier versus them.

to be a a shockabsorber for your frontline troops?
Why the fuck would you on the otherhand want a fucking KT?
To put it simple it was a cheap brick at about 400 man and 160 fule that could act as a pushed to decrew MGs without fearing the loss of an expensive unit.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on April 02, 2013, 04:12:53 pm
to be a a shockabsorber for your frontline troops?
Why the fuck would you on the otherhand want a fucking KT?
To put it simple it was a cheap brick at about 400 man and 160 fule that could act as a pushed to decrew MGs without fearing the loss of an expensive unit.
Exactly, plus the tank shock machine gun 6 pdr


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: TheIcelandicManiac on April 02, 2013, 04:14:59 pm
Exactly, plus the tank shock machine gun 6 pdr

Well they did fix that think quite quickly after royalfaps started abusing it.

Ontop of that it was never in the way, it was a simple t1 unlock stacked besides the AVRE(cant actually remember its placement but oh well) and people could easily choose if they wanted one or not just as much with the AVRE, now its 2 bottom unlocks completly useless unless you really want either one of those units.

Honestly i think the removal of the unit was as stupid as the removal of the assult engies and Assult rifles.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: Hicks58 on April 02, 2013, 04:21:53 pm
I still use the MK VI and like it quite a bit.

Why? It's a 75mm Sherman gun with Churchill armour and up to 42.5-45 range when combined with a CCT. Spells doom for most infantry and support weapons you get your mitts on. Had one get about 26 inf kills last game I played, was good shit.

The tank works well if you play it creeping advance with support weapons and Tommy's. It falls flat on it's face if you try to use a mobile force. Use a Cromwell if you want to do that.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: terrapinsrock on April 02, 2013, 04:29:25 pm
Why buy a MKVI when you can just buy a Mobile Rapewagon, I mean um, the Bofors HT and get the same or more amount of kills at a fraction of the cost?


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on April 02, 2013, 04:43:52 pm
Because ones a reward/warmap unit the other is supposed to be a core doctrinal unlock for rse.
There's also the 500 or so hp difference and play style.
Apple's and oranges terrapin.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: aeroblade56 on November 11, 2013, 05:59:29 pm
N-N-N-N-Necrooo.



Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on December 28, 2013, 09:13:14 am
Please do something to make this unit actually useful ?

ATM its an utter joke of a unit

its just a wasted unlock in its current state

Why would I pay ( mind you I am) 410mp and 260fu for a unit that is easily overshadowed by a Cromwell costing 370mp and 200fu.

Its hardly a cost effective dmg soak at that price.

DO SOMETHING!


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: nikomas on December 28, 2013, 09:22:09 am
Quote
with decent acc vs inf
It's posts like this that make me think you have zero understand of what weapons and stats units and weapons have.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on December 28, 2013, 09:23:23 am
It's posts like this that make me thing you have zero understand of what weapons some units actually have.

I know it has a carbon copy Sherman 75mm

but pound for pound Sherman always seems far more accurate vs inf (not to mention the extra 2pop for cct)


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: nikomas on December 28, 2013, 09:24:19 am
So you admit it's the exact same thing, yet the sherman "Seems" better?

Think about that for a second, I will also confirm that it is in fact the exact same gun.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on December 28, 2013, 09:28:48 am
So you admit it's the exact same thing, yet the sherman "Seems" better?

Think about that for a second, I will also confirm that it is in fact the exact same gun.

well I don't recall what acc buffs shermans get from various doctrines.

But Churchill gets that 10% acc whilst stationary which is quite useless for a slow lumbering tank that's outrun by inf.

but the way I see it is you get a Sherman for 12 pop working at 100% capacity
and you get a Churchill mk6 for 12 pop working at 80% capacity unless you fork out for a CCT for extra 2 pop to get it working at 100% of its potential capacity.

Now the AVRE is a cost efficient anti support weapon, the CROC is a cost efficient anti inf weapon.

And then we have the MK6 who costs almost as much as a CROC, yet is obsolete in the intended role.

OH and don't get me started on the MK6s unshocking shocking tankshock.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: I2ay on December 29, 2013, 12:47:03 am
OH and don't get me started on the MK6s unshocking shocking tankshock.
Fix tank shock and the unit is fixed. GO GO GO


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: Shabtajus on December 29, 2013, 01:54:15 am
Dont be so sceptic about MK. Few guys use them very good and dat unit works fine. Etc mysthalun or ray they provide good support for dat tank and play with it smart so its hella hard kill it. L2tank


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: aeroblade56 on December 29, 2013, 02:38:32 am
Having witnessed I2ay use them. i wasn't impressed to much.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on December 29, 2013, 02:46:26 am
Its just a rubbish unit, for an extra two pop you can get a croc which makes mk6 look like a bren carrier.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: deadbolt on December 29, 2013, 09:55:11 am
apologies for poor english, i am russia

when were you when churchill is dies

i was at home watching church crocodile

nikolai calls me

'mk6 is kill'

'no'


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: tank130 on December 29, 2013, 01:04:31 pm
^^  lol


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on January 23, 2014, 02:41:26 pm
So..... shit with doctrines.
and I ddidn't think it possible but shitter without doctrines.

 Recall a 3v3 the other day featuring 5 mk6s.
10 kills between them.

 OP no ?


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: TheIcelandicManiac on January 23, 2014, 03:24:30 pm
Ye thats why the mk4 was good, you could field a fuckton of them and even tough they didnt kill a lot they would serve their purpose with field presence
as you could just use the rest of the fule for things like cromms.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: NightRain on January 23, 2014, 03:42:40 pm
Ye thats why the mk4 was good, you could field a fuckton of them and even tough they didnt kill a lot they would serve their purpose with field presence
as you could just use the rest of the fule for things like cromms.

They had 47% chance to pounce from a ostwind. Just because you can field a shit tons of shit on the field doesn't mean it'll be useful.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: Shabtajus on January 23, 2014, 03:56:01 pm
They had 47% chance to pounce from a ostwind. Just because you can field a shit tons of shit on the field doesn't mean it'll be useful.
Oh speedy u r so wrong man so so wrong. In eirr enviroment amount of even shitty units is essential thing to win via spam


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: terrapinsrock on January 23, 2014, 05:22:36 pm
Yea played against Hicks and Nikomas when they were using them the other day.

Our Gwagons and Marders pretty much slaughtered them without the Mk6s doing much damage from what I remembered


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on January 23, 2014, 06:08:25 pm
Oh speedy u r so wrong man so so wrong. In eirr enviroment amount of even shitty units is essential thing to win via spam

oath shabby boy mk4s with bottom t4 sprint with rest of pop in piats


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: Hicks58 on January 23, 2014, 06:17:41 pm
Yea played against Hicks and Nikomas when they were using them the other day.

Our Gwagons and Marders pretty much slaughtered them without the Mk6s doing much damage from what I remembered

Yeah. I had one in my company and it got shredded by Marder and Geschitz fire.

I'll take a look into the penetration rates tomorrow.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: aeroblade56 on January 23, 2014, 06:25:48 pm
Yea played against Hicks and Nikomas when they were using them the other day.

Our Gwagons and Marders pretty much slaughtered them without the Mk6s doing much damage from what I remembered

i think across 4-5 they got maybe 8 kills and i dont think any of them got a repair off.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: XIIcorps on January 23, 2014, 06:32:41 pm
Yeah. I had one in my company and it got shredded by Marder and Geschitz fire.

I'll take a look into the penetration rates tomorrow.
honestly man if we could make it mich harder to pen from the front I dont think it would be OP.
if you cant flank a fucking churchill you do not deserve to have fingers.


Title: Re: Churchill mk 6 "unicorn"
Post by: deadbolt on January 24, 2014, 06:06:23 am
honestly man if we could make it mich harder to pen from the front I dont think it would be OP.
if you cant flank a fucking churchill you do not deserve to have fingers.

this