It does make more sense. Though I still believe someone objective enough can point out when something is OP without playing it themselves. I played against basic infantry spam with mostly just nades on them backed by mass heavy support weapons and heavy armor. I didn't have any artillery or indirect fire to beat it. I was... so soundly beaten. But it wasn't OP. I just didn't have the counters in my company.
...though now that I'm thinking about it... I think Tym's point was directed more towards the irrational knee-jerk sissies... So I think I'll shush now
Right Mal. It's directed more towards the Knee Jerk guys who come out and yell something is OP but have either never played with that doctrine, used that ability or just got owned by it. Every now n then there's something legit (Demos OP, is a bug, stags being OP with canister shot but nerf wasn't needed but w/e) but a lot of times I have seen that it's not the case