Home
Forum
Search
Login
Register
Account
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Did you miss your
activation email?
November 25, 2024, 08:23:08 pm
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Resources
Leaderboards
Unit Price Lists
Map List
Launcher status:
Players in chat: 0
Battles in progress: 0
Battles waiting: 5
Download the mod from Steam
Join our Discord server
Recent posts
Please don’t open this th...
by
Olazaika1
[November 01, 2024, 12:46:37 pm]
Required age ratings for ...
by
Unkn0wn
[October 05, 2024, 07:29:20 am]
50 minutes cap victory
by
Olazaika1
[September 05, 2024, 01:54:13 pm]
Feedback
by
Olazaika1
[July 16, 2024, 11:30:34 pm]
Anyone here still alive?
by
Olazaika1
[June 22, 2024, 06:49:40 am]
very glad to be signing u...
by
Olazaika1
[March 08, 2024, 12:13:38 am]
EiR:R ACA (Art Credits Ar...
by
Olazaika1
[March 08, 2024, 12:12:54 am]
Hello, New guy in the mod
by
Olazaika1
[March 08, 2024, 12:09:37 am]
CoH 3 Old Guard
by
chefarzt
[December 30, 2023, 08:00:58 pm]
KT got buffs, Rug stop hi...
by
LittleJoe
[February 04, 2023, 11:46:41 am]
Awards
2007
Mod of the Year
Editor's Choice
2008
Most Innovative Multiplayer
Nominee
Want to help promote Europe In Ruins? It's as easy as clicking here once a day!
Why?
COH: Europe In Ruins
>
Forum
>
EIR Main Forums
>
Balance & Design
>
Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Down
Print
Author
Topic: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam (Read 6874 times)
0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
on:
August 18, 2009, 03:08:34 pm »
Don't take this the wrong way, as an Axis player it may seem that I'm just biased, but I think I have a legitimate point.
I believe Relic went a little overboard on certain abilities in the pursuit of interesting battles and we are blindly accepting it as part of the game when it is technically broken. I'm sure many will disagree but I would much rather fight tactically than rely on specials to ruin the enemy's vet.
Examples:
Treadbreaker
Button
Faust's critical table
PIATs/sticky's ability to fire through anything when StuH's can't
Tank shock (in it's current form, where every inf in radius goes red instantly)
Slow
Stun
I know some of these require skill to implement so are not just "I win buttons" but some of them are. Traditionally, every unit has a certain counter and when you see a certain unit attacking, you maneuver to get your counter in play with the enemy. However, in these cases, there is little to nothing you can do about it. Normally if you see a lot of heavy tanks, you deploy AT's in key locations, or if you see a blob you set up MGs (unless they're AB or ranger), but in most of these cases, you can lose some serious units by "accident" because you can't use retreat or do anything at all to counter the ability. That spells not imbalanced, but "imbalanceable" in my book. I believe they are by definition a broken aspect of the game.
I know everyone uses them but they make for extreme frustration, and I don't believe they are good for the game. Of course I personally hate button from Kangaroos and Stun, because they ensure that I never can retreat my tanks, but every ability has it's level of issues.
It's not that they are all bad abilities, but in their current state of effectiveness, they often allow players to purchase the deaths of enemy units without really the chance of being countered. The price varies greatly, but often it's ridiculously cheap. E.G. 40 mun for tank shock often causes the inevitable deaths of 1000s of manpower and mun worth of infantry, and there's no excuse like "they shouldn't have been standing there" because the magic button says "LIE DOWN!"
*dons NOMEX*
«
Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 06:12:08 pm by VERTIGGO
»
Logged
TOV units = intentionally OP marketing gimmicks
Jazlizard
EIR Veteran
Posts: 691
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #1 on:
August 18, 2009, 03:28:22 pm »
Some of the abilities you listed are a bit hard to balance as their power level scales dramatically based on skill level, both of the person using them, and the person you use them against.
Take button for example, on it's own it doesn't do that much, it slows down your tank and makes it (well most of them anyways) not able to defend itself very well. It takes another unit (an AT unit) to really do damage to the target. At it's best you could probably take out any tank in the game with a couple units with button and the right amount of AT, at it's worst you button a tank for .5 seconds and it backs away.
Some folks would argue that you should always balance for the highest potential of a weapon. I tend to take a more middle of the road approach with it myself, while still leaning towards the elite play level.
Bottom line is, you can't price button (or any other ability) like every time it's used it will take out a panther, or a tiger. Same with stickies, against a great player, you might not ever get to throw one.
Ease of use is another factor to consider, you mentioned fausts which are for the most part click, aim, fire. Easy to use, hit almost all the time, but have a long cooldown and for the most part, just do damage, much simpler item to balance out.
Anyways, the point is, they aren't unable to be balanced, but they require more thought and understanding of abilities and weapons available on a larger scale then some other abilities.
I do agree with the premise that the more abilities/units you have the harder it is to balance everything, but that doesn't make it impossible, just makes it harder, but I, for one, prefer more variation than less.
«
Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 03:54:11 pm by Jazlizard
»
Logged
Quote from: Phil
The MOD is over. The war is over. We're too lazy to restart it. You can all go fuck pickles mom, I hear she's easy.
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #2 on:
August 18, 2009, 04:06:26 pm »
Very good points! Again, I'm not fighting for removal of any of these abilities totally, as I think they are interesting (some more than others) and in the right way add depth to the game. Stickies are very legitimate, since they don't always throw if you micro carefully, and don't entirely disable the vehicle. Overall, good balance. Slow I think is similar, since it is one infantry squad, which is not as game breaking as a heavy tank or whatnot, and it doesn't kill the infantry outright. Treadbreaker often fails to work, though I haven't seen it much. However, some abilities are just far to inescapable, to be fair. Tank shock is bugged, I understand, and can and will (I believe) be fixed. However, button and stun are continuing issues. When I had precision strike, I would pay for a second one just as some insurance against bren squads, since without dropping an off-map, it's almost certain death for any tank. However, the instant it's buttoned, it not only stops and quits firing, it is completely blind, so often I couldn't even waste an off-map just to scare away the tommy squad. That's a bit one sided, and add a Kangaroo with PIATs as well, and you have a circle strafing tractor beam of death that cannot be countered with anything. There's simply no time to kill the Kangaroo even if you have PaKs in range before the PIATs finish off the tank.
Bottom line is this. EIRR was meant to revolve around victory by taking the field, and whoever is losing retreats before they lose everything. It makes sense that when your infantry is half destroyed, you retreat, and civil players don't set up traps for them or chase down vet all the way to spawn. However, losing a tank with full health and no engine damage because someone happened to have a tractor beam handy is not even sportsmanlike. I would much rather have to deal with incredible allied AT (oh wait, I do) and run away if I get the worst of an engagement than remain constantly nervous waiting for that Kangaroo ambush or T17 rush is going to totally annihilate my vet tanks without warning or chance to run away. I shouldn't have to shadow my Panther with PaKs just to keep it from certain death.
Logged
mapleleafsnation
EIR Regular
Posts: 33
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #3 on:
August 18, 2009, 04:58:59 pm »
The tractor beam of death is one of my favorite weapon as British and it dies fairly quickly, unless the enemy tank is unsupported. Tanks that get buttoned can be rescued by infantry.
I do agree that tank shock is really powerful, just run your churchill in the middle of the enemy blob and BOOM everyone rolls on the ground. Then send in the tractor beam of death and everyone's running away.
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 04:06:26 pm
I personally hate button from Kangaroos
You can button WITH (or from inside) the kangoroo?
«
Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 05:13:39 pm by mapleleafsnation
»
Logged
spinn72
EIR Veteran
Posts: 1802
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #4 on:
August 18, 2009, 05:04:53 pm »
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 03:08:34 pm
PIATs/sticky's ability to fire through anything when StuH's can't
If a Stuh could, then an AVRE would too. Would you want that??? lol.
btw most of these abilities are critical to the team. Basic Whermact tactics say you shouldnt get close to riflemen you think have stickies or Brens.
Logged
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #5 on:
August 18, 2009, 05:46:05 pm »
Quote from: mapleleafsnation on August 18, 2009, 04:58:59 pm
The tractor beam of death is one of my favorite weapon as British and it dies fairly quickly, unless the enemy tank is unsupported. Tanks that get buttoned can be rescued by infantry.
I do agree that tank shock is really powerful, just run your churchill in the middle of the enemy blob and BOOM everyone rolls on the ground. Then send in the tractor beam of death and everyone's running away.
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 04:06:26 pm
I personally hate button from Kangaroos
You can button WITH (or from inside) the kangoroo?
Yes, the Kangaroo can circle strafe a tank, while buttoning, and holds multiple squads, so it can button while moving and firing PIATs. Since a P4 dies in 2-3 volleys from PIATS, you can't get 6 shots off on the Kangaroo even with supporting PaKs or tanks before it's dead.
Logged
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #6 on:
August 18, 2009, 05:51:56 pm »
Quote from: spinn72 on August 18, 2009, 05:04:53 pm
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 03:08:34 pm
PIATs/sticky's ability to fire through anything when StuH's can't
If a Stuh could, then an AVRE would too. Would you want that??? lol.
btw most of these abilities are critical to the team. Basic Whermact tactics say you shouldnt get close to riflemen you think have stickies or Brens.
One way or the other, you can't say one unit is allowed to fire over things and another isn't. Personally, I don't think anything should have one-way mirror capabilities. The churchill has no problem because it simply drives through hedge and its so strong it has no problem with frontal assaults. The StuH is so weak and slow it's worthless in hedges because it has to creep around the corners to get any shots off, while the PIATs are magically soaring through any blockage. The PIAT has the same buff that stickies have (albeit need), in that they fire through anything. It's supposedly because they are ballistic, but it's nonsense because it doesn't matter how big or high the obstacle is. The StuH supposedly has ballistics as well, but somehow magically hits anything in front of it, even small hedges that it should be able to fire over.
«
Last Edit: August 18, 2009, 05:54:54 pm by VERTIGGO
»
Logged
Mysthalin
Tired King of Stats
Posts: 9028
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #7 on:
August 19, 2009, 03:15:10 am »
The kangaroo will die to a single pak + shrek long before it will kill the tank it's buttoning. And the casualty rate on a dead kangaroo is simply HUGE. Anything that didn't get out before the boom go out with the boom :S.
Logged
Two
EIR Veteran
Posts: 2079
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #8 on:
August 19, 2009, 03:26:44 am »
Quote from: Mysthalin on August 19, 2009, 03:15:10 am
The kangaroo will die to a single pak + shrek long before it will kill the tank it's buttoning. And the casualty rate on a dead kangaroo is simply HUGE. Anything that didn't get out before the boom go out with the boom :S.
Even if they get out they have to do it when the kangaroo can still take 2 hits. When i ran my tiger company everyone would hop out when all it took was 1 shot to kill, id hit the roo, ko it and the splash would insta kill the units that jumped out.
Logged
Quote
IplayForKeeps: if we were an equation
IplayForKeeps: it would be
IplayForKeeps: two = keeps
IplayForKeeps: i only have 1 friend
lionel23
Donator
Posts: 1854
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #9 on:
August 19, 2009, 08:21:41 am »
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 05:51:56 pm
Quote from: spinn72 on August 18, 2009, 05:04:53 pm
Quote from: VERTIGGO on August 18, 2009, 03:08:34 pm
PIATs/sticky's ability to fire through anything when StuH's can't
If a Stuh could, then an AVRE would too. Would you want that??? lol.
btw most of these abilities are critical to the team. Basic Whermact tactics say you shouldnt get close to riflemen you think have stickies or Brens.
One way or the other, you can't say one unit is allowed to fire over things and another isn't. Personally, I don't think anything should have one-way mirror capabilities. The churchill has no problem because it simply drives through hedge and its so strong it has no problem with frontal assaults. The StuH is so weak and slow it's worthless in hedges because it has to creep around the corners to get any shots off, while the PIATs are magically soaring through any blockage. The PIAT has the same buff that stickies have (albeit need), in that they fire through anything. It's supposedly because they are ballistic, but it's nonsense because it doesn't matter how big or high the obstacle is. The StuH supposedly has ballistics as well, but somehow magically hits anything in front of it, even small hedges that it should be able to fire over.
Well, do remember originally the StuH wasn't ballistic but had a cannon like the 88 and tended to miss because of the direct fire. The StuH was always weird with how it was the only tank to 'lob' shells from such short range, heh.
Logged
Congratulations, dear sir...I must say, never before have I seen such precise gunnery displayed. - CrazyWR (on Leaderboard Howitzers)
Malevolence
Donator
Posts: 1871
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #10 on:
August 19, 2009, 10:18:08 am »
Quote
Well, do remember originally the StuH wasn't ballistic but had a cannon like the 88 and tended to miss because of the direct fire. The StuH was always weird with how it was the only tank to 'lob' shells from such short range, heh.
It hit a LOT more often and was borderline overpowered because it shot a p4 shell with a 105 charge in it.
Logged
Akranadas' Greatest Hits, Volume 1:
Quote from: Akranadas
Vet has nothing to do with unit preformance.
Quote from: Akranadas
We are serious about enforcing this, and I am sure you all want to be able to have your balance thought considered by the development team with some biased, sensationalist coming into your thread and ruining it.
Unkn0wn
No longer retired
Posts: 18379
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics
«
Reply #11 on:
August 19, 2009, 10:30:28 am »
Quote from: Malevolence on August 19, 2009, 10:18:08 am
Quote
Well, do remember originally the StuH wasn't ballistic but had a cannon like the 88 and tended to miss because of the direct fire. The StuH was always weird with how it was the only tank to 'lob' shells from such short range, heh.
It hit a LOT more often and was borderline overpowered because it shot a p4 shell with a 105 charge in it.
Good times indeed.
Logged
Mysthalin
Tired King of Stats
Posts: 9028
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #12 on:
August 19, 2009, 11:18:34 am »
Yeah, good days.
Back then I couldn't even tell the difference between it and the normal StuG, so I used it as such, thinking it was just a no-fuel version
.
Logged
Pak88mm
EIR Veteran
Posts: 423
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #13 on:
August 19, 2009, 11:25:32 am »
pretty much sums up alot of the balance issues with current VCoH. Their balance team is just not a balance team at all. Those abilities are just for noobs and lend themselves to be abuse hardcore by good players. so instead of adding a level playing field they make it far worse.
Logged
Exactly.
There is only so many times you can slaughter Lt Apollo, Rocksitter, and Alwaysloseguy24 before you get bored and fall asleep.
-GamesGuy-
Most Hated player in EiR....Pak88Mm
Freek
EIR Veteran
Posts: 218
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #14 on:
August 19, 2009, 01:30:48 pm »
Heh, it would be an interesting game without ANY abilities.. and maybe even NO upgrades. (Though, allied AT would need a general buff vs axis heavy tanks).
Logged
pernik
EIR Veteran
Posts: 196
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #15 on:
August 19, 2009, 01:46:55 pm »
mmm i'd like to see a game without offmaps, and those replaced with onmap pieces
oops, a lil thread derail
Logged
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #16 on:
August 19, 2009, 02:07:21 pm »
Maybe but a lot of those offmaps have the tractor beam syndrome as well. I mean sector is just devastating, and strafe hits with no smoke, heck there's an allied strike that lands super fast has at least 9 arty rounds and is so accurate it's killed a panther and p4 in one strike, even thought they tried to back out...
Logged
pernik
EIR Veteran
Posts: 196
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #17 on:
August 19, 2009, 02:30:21 pm »
that's why I'd like to see a game without it
Logged
VERTIGGO
EIR Veteran
Posts: 392
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #18 on:
August 22, 2009, 01:58:32 pm »
actually I'm not sure what you mean..
Logged
pernik
EIR Veteran
Posts: 196
Re: Imbalanceable abilities and tactics: The Death Star Tractor Beam
«
Reply #19 on:
August 22, 2009, 02:22:51 pm »
I mean that EiRR w/o or with the very least offmaps would be great (and instead of offmaps I'd like to see on-map pieces such as Priest or Hummel)
nvm
Logged
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Up
Print
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
News & Introductions
-----------------------------
=> Updates & Announcements
=> EIR Boot Camp
===> In Other Languages
=====> In Chinese
=====> In German
=====> In Spanish
=====> In Polish
=====> In French
=====> In Norwegian
=> New Players
-----------------------------
EIR Main Forums
-----------------------------
=> General Discussion
=> Tactics & Strategy
=> Balance & Design
=> Broadcasts & Replays
=> Projects & Mapping
=> Technical Support
===> Bug Reporting
-----------------------------
General Forums
-----------------------------
=> General Discussion
=> Other Games
TinyPortal v1.0 beta 4 ©
Bloc
Loading...