These comments are directed to the posters of this replay, and there are spoilers so ye be warned.
Things I liked:
-The way you handled the pershings. Constant flanking and scavenging of allied AT allowed you to deal with them effectively.
-Katusha's 1 man schreck squads. You got some balls keeping those on the field for as long as you did, but great usage nonetheless.
-using smoke for assaults
-specific attention paid to keeping units in green cover during most fights
-no blobbing
-late Wehr HTs to mop up random no upgrade infantry
-running over LeTon's sniper with the panther.
Things I didnt like:
-2 tanks were repaired at the front line. The panther you could get away with to possibly save it, but the P4 IST was repaired on front line with 1/3 HP left and no dmged engine. It died needlessly.
Addition: Just saw a puma do the same in front of a pershing. Your lucky the pershing died.
-Loose schrecks kill ketts... <_< ERrr.. w/e pick up dropped schrecks earlier. If it was me, they wouldve been stolen and used against you.
-A hummel was forced off the field after 5 minutes of play by a flanking sherman. This should never happen. You pretty much allowed a sherman and ATG to sneak past and position itself into your spawn.
Watch your flanks ffs!
-nebel died needlessly too. keep it back. You cant loose all your arty when attacking.
-This was a 7/10 until i noticed how often the P4 ISTs had rear armor facing zooks and other such AT. 1/2 deduction of a point for that.
-turn off your profanity filter, dummy. (i forget who it was) lol j/k
Score: 6.5/10
Overview: Overall, I liked the replay. Good atk/def. game, very intense and you guys took your time to make coordinated pushes. Repairing on the front lines is a big no no, however. Losing the arty early was big also. When taking on a pershing with a panther, if your micro isnt top notch, disengage. Try to keep the pershing perpendicular to your tank instead of driving straight past and getting on his rear. Only do that when you got an opening and do not have to reface yourself. It was very intense and because of the hectic nature im sure mistakes were made, lapses in micro, etc. 6.5 isnt a bad score, im just trying to establish a serious scale. It is a very watchable game, gj on the win
