[FINAL]The Rhine/[BETA]The Black Forest

[Guest]

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever

Login with username, password and session length

[Cam51]

They are both pretty much 'finals', but they require a bit of EiR testing, and it doesn't see like people are using these maps (not sure why, maybe th size but nothing a half track can't fix).

The Rhine, FINAL

http://files.filefront.com/The+Rhine+EIRsga/;8394107;;/fileinfo.html

The Black Forest

http://files.filefront.com/The+Black+Forest+EIRsga/;8334555;;/fileinfo.html

[attachment deleted by admin]

[Migi2]

I have checked these both out , Loved the balance and detail on both , great work man.

[Apex]

Very nice maps!
Although the rhine can often end in a stalemate. For EiR i would add another infantry only bridge across the rhine in the centre between where the very small river next to the small town melts into the rhine and the parking lot area.

[TheDeadlyShoe]

A cross-river rail bridge or two would work.

[Kotori]

the capture points arent distinguished on the tactical map in all places....and i think they should be a little bigger and possibly more than one in the city areas. But atleast make them show up on tactical map, was hard trying to find anything to capture.

[Kolath]

Agreed with Katori, his comment refers to Rhine.  I really enjoyed the map!  Excellent work and attention to detail.

Couple suggestions:

1. Make the spawn sectors larger, this will make them more visible, and ensure that spawning players will be able to cap them before they run out!

2. Make some sort of crossing, perhaps a footbridge, over the watery ravine that divides the large side of the map.  Also, you it would be cool to make some spaces for infantry between some of the groves.

3. Be sure to let Unk0wn know when you finish the final version so he can put it in the map database.

Overall, though, a great map!

[Cam51]

The Rhine is a final.

Links updated.

[Lai]

Black Forest contains too many chokepoints and four spawn sectors each that count towards VPs are too much. It's really easy for defenders to force a draw, which count as a win for them...

[DasGuntLord01]

Black Forest contains too many chokepoints and four spawn sectors each that count towards VPs are too much. It's really easy for defenders to force a draw, which count as a win for them...

Too many choke points?

The only problem I had with the map was the territories.  This is CoH's fault, because maps this big don't really ever exist, but it's sometimes impossible to see the territory boundaries.

Also, you should get rid of the 'whole-map territory and the 4 spawn territories.

The size of the map is perfect for an EiR 4v4.  It is entirely possible in Black Forest to have 30 different firefights in 35 different locations.

I thought the choke points where very well done.   There were enough to make some positions very important, but each position was flankable, which meant that stale-mates never happened.

[Thtb]

The black forest is my favorite 4v4 map.

We coud need some good 1v1´s.

[Bonte]

yeah blackforrest is my favorite 4v4...alows for long heated games...