FF can beat a Tiger or KT easy, non doctrine tank beating doctrine tank? Fail!
a ff can't beat a tiger or kt easy get off it. 1 v 1 they both have too much health and all it takes is 4 hits from each tank to take out the FF while it will take at least 10 from the FF (9 to kill Tiger, 14 for king tiger). A Panther has a better chance beating a Pershing or Croc than a FF would against either Tigers. And it is absolutely no match for a Jagdpanther, it's much too fast.
I'm sorry, but are you seriously saying that the Crocodile fails because it's an über anti-infantry tank that gets raped by general purpose or specifically anti-tank tanks that cost 200+ fuel more than it? Same for Pershing failing against Panther, Pershing can fight tanks but is not meant for it, Panther is 500 fuel invested to a pure anti-tank platform. Sure it can get some infantry kills with lucky shots, but then again so can ATGs and Marders, and you wouldn't consider those general purpose units good for fighting both inf and tanks.
P4s don't really win against M10s with both players being skilled because the M10 has much better range and speed.
I didn't say it fails, i said it's not really a match for anything on the axis above a p4 (panther, tiger, king tiger, jagdpanther) also the range on the m10 wont make much of a difference because its only +5 and its hard as hell to kite that 5 range.
lol pershing not meant to fight tanks? really? just because it's really good vs infantry doesn't mean its not meant to fight tanks. The stats it has says other wise. It has a 10% dmg buff vs panthers and jagdpanthers, and when you buy the 76mm upgrade, it gives the pershing the hvap which increases its penetration vs heavy armor.
also, the panther is a much better ai platform than an at gun.
AT gun = .15 acc vs infantry
panther = .60 acc vs infantry.
p4 = .75 acc
so while the p4 has more splash so it can take out more than one infantry at a time, the panther is quite good at sniping infantry. I've seen well microed panthers and jagdpanthers get 20+ infantry kills in a single game.
so i reiterate, axis elite units are its armor, allies get infantry, thats just how it is. Once you start to change that, you start to mess with the balance.
Axis - Infantry & Support Weapons Support Armor
Allies - Armor and Support Weapons Support Infantry